How much of an SEO audit is repetition?
Most SEO audits hand you a list with a row for every page a problem sits on. Alt text missing on 80 product pages is 80 rows; a theme that leaves out image sizes is a row on every page it builds. So we asked how much of such a list is the same problem said again. We audited 330 small sites, up to 100 pages each, and counted both: the rows, and the problems behind them.
On the median site, 627 rows came down to 19 problems: 32 rows for each one. On a quarter of the sites it was more than 43 rows a problem, on a quarter fewer than 23.
| Per site | Lower quarter | Median | Upper quarter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rows: one for every page a problem sits on | 402 | 627 | 799 |
| Problems: the same findings, each counted once | 15 | 19 | 23 |
| Rows for each problem | 22.7 | 32.1 | 43.7 |
Across all 330 sites, 205,941 rows were 6,281 problems. A row isn’t wrong: each one is a page where the problem really is. But the fix is rarely made page by page. A missing image size or a title that runs too long usually comes from a template, and one change to the template clears every row it made.
More pages, more rows. Not more problems
| Sites | How many | Median rows | Median problems | Rows for each problem |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| We read 100 pages | 227 | 716 | 20 | 36.1 |
| The archive had fewer than 100 | 103 | 330 | 18 | 20.6 |
Read 100 pages instead of 40 and the list grows with them; the problems hardly move. We stopped at 100 pages a site, so for any site bigger than that, a crawl of every page would most likely list more rows for much the same problems.
The problems small sites have most
Of the sites each check could run on, the share with that problem on at least one page:
| Check | What it finds | Sites with it | Share | A warning or worse on |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PERF-001 | Images without declared dimensions | 297 | 90.0% | 297 |
| AI-002 | No short answer under the heading | 279 | 84.5% | 0 |
| CONTENT-004 | Very low text-to-HTML ratio | 270 | 81.8% | 0 |
| LINK-002 | Generic anchor text | 263 | 79.7% | 0 |
| ONPAGE-005 | Meta description outside the useful range | 263 | 79.7% | 0 |
| ONPAGE-008 | Skipped heading level | 263 | 79.7% | 0 |
| ONPAGE-002 | Title too long | 245 | 74.2% | 238 |
| CONTENT-001 | Thin content | 234 | 70.9% | 200 |
| ONPAGE-004 | Meta description missing | 215 | 65.2% | 42 |
| ONPAGE-006 | H1 missing | 214 | 64.8% | 186 |
| INDEX-003 | Canonical missing | 207 | 62.7% | 207 |
| LINK-001 | Too many links on the page | 204 | 61.8% | 0 |
| STRUCT-001 | The page has no structured data | 202 | 61.2% | 0 |
| PERF-002 | Too many blocking resources in the head | 198 | 60.0% | 0 |
| CONTENT-002 | Images without alternative text | 183 | 55.5% | 179 |
The last column matters as much as the share. Most sites have a generic link text or a skipped heading level somewhere, and our audit calls those notices, not warnings. Images without width and height, a title over 70 characters and a missing canonical are warnings, and they are about as common. The full table, every check, is in the data.
How we did it
- The sites. The 10,000 domains Study 1 drew at random from ranks 100,000 to 1,000,000 of the Tranco list of 13 October 2026 (N26LW), taken in that drawn order until 330 had at least 20 HTML pages that answered 200 in Common Crawl’s October 2026 crawl. That took 981 domains.
- The pages. We didn’t ask the sites. Every page is the copy Common Crawl archived, read from its archive. For each site: the address (https or http, with or without www) with the most pages, its home page, then pages drawn at random, up to 100. 28,483 pages in all, a median of 100 a site. Pages the site’s robots.txt keeps our crawler from were left out, as our crawler leaves them out.
- The audit. Our own engine, version 0.34.1, the one our audits ran in November 2026: every check that can be run on an archived copy, scored and grouped as our report groups them.
- What we counted. Rows: one for every page a problem sits on, and one for a problem of the whole site. Problems: the same findings, one for each check and severity, as our report lists them. A check that charges some pages as a warning and others as a notice counts twice.
Checking our own numbers
We drew 30 pages at random, one from each of 30 sites, and had them judged by a second reader that never saw our code or what it said: another AI model, working from the HTML alone, on 13 of the checks a page’s HTML can settle by itself (title, description, headings, language, viewport, noindex, canonical, image sizes, alt text, structured data). One copy we couldn’t keep, as our antivirus removed it on download. On the other 29 pages, 376 of 377 verdicts agreed.
The one that didn’t was a page asking not to be indexed, like most pages built from the same template on its site. Our audit reports that once, as a setting of the template, not as a problem on every page, so it makes no row. The reader, going by the check alone, counted it.
Before that, an earlier check found a bug in our own crawler. It read every page as UTF-8, so on sites written in another encoding (windows-1251, GBK, ISO-8859-1), each letter outside ASCII came out as a replacement character: titles turned into rows of them, and a Chinese title counted up to twice its length. 23 of the 330 sites were read that way. We fixed the crawler; since version 0.34.1 it reads a page in the encoding the page declares, in our audits too. Those sites were read again, and every figure here is from after the fix. The medians didn’t move.
We also left out 16 pages whose copy in the archive stops partway through: part of a page, with its links and text cut, isn’t a page to audit.
What this can’t tell you
- Small sites only. Ranks 100,000 to 1,000,000, and only those with 20 pages or more in the archive: 330 of 981. Sites that block Common Crawl, send every page to another domain, or have only a few pages aren’t here.
- October’s copies, not the sites today. And no JavaScript was run. On 17 sites most pages build their content in the browser; without them, the median is 30.8 rows a problem instead of 32.1.
- Fewer checks than a full audit. Some checks need what an archive doesn’t keep: a sitemap, the site’s other addresses, redirects followed live, page speed, Search Console. They aren’t counted, so a full audit lists more rows and more problems than this one. The list is below.
- Some shares only one way. A link counts as dead only if Common Crawl kept the dead page’s answer, and duplicate titles and descriptions are found only among the pages we read: those are at least what the table says. Pages that look empty without JavaScript are counted without the browser our audits open for them: that one is at most.
- Our rows, not every tool’s. The count of rows depends on which checks a tool runs. Another tool, with other checks, would list a different number. What this measures is the shape of a per-page list, not any one product’s.
The checks an archive can’t answer, and why:
| Check | What it finds | Why it isn’t counted |
|---|---|---|
| CRAWL-001 | Sitemap URLs blocked by robots.txt | no sitemap is read |
| CRAWL-002 | Response other than 200 | only pages that answered 200 are drawn |
| CRAWL-003 | Redirect chain | redirects are not followed from the archive |
| CRAWL-004 | Page missing from the sitemap | no sitemap is read |
| CRAWL-007 | Pages that could not be downloaded at all | a page Common Crawl could not download is not in the archive |
| CRAWL-008 | The site is published on two addresses | the site’s other addresses are not asked for |
| CRAWL-009 | http:// serves the site instead of redirecting to https:// | the site’s other addresses are not asked for |
| CRAWL-010 | Sitemap lists pages that should not be there | no sitemap is read |
| GSC-001 | Many impressions, very few clicks | no Search Console data |
| GSC-002 | Close to the first page | no Search Console data |
| GSC-003 | Page with traffic that asks not to be indexed | no Search Console data |
| GSC-004 | Pages competing for the same search | no Search Console data |
| INDEX-008 | Missing pages answer 200 | no address that cannot exist is asked for |
| LINK-005 | Orphan pages | a sample of pages, not the whole site, so no page can be called an orphan |
| LINK-007 | Pages reached by one internal link only | a sample of pages, not the whole site, so no page can be called an orphan |
| PERF-003 | LCP above 2.5 s | no PageSpeed measurement |
| PERF-005 | Layout shifts while loading (CLS) | no PageSpeed measurement |
| PERF-006 | Slow response to clicks and taps (INP) | no PageSpeed measurement |
| PERF-007 | Images heavier than 200 KB | images are not downloaded and weighed |
The data
On Zenodo, doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24173724: the totals, every check with how many sites it ran on and found, and one line for each site with its rows, problems and the checks it failed, with the method in full. No domain and no rank is in the data: below the top 10,000, as our bot page promises, nothing is published site by site that names a site. The data is CC BY 4.0. The audit engine is our product and its code isn’t published; what each check finds, and why, is on its own page. To have a domain taken out of the data, write to bot@trakis.io.
Sources
- Tranco, list N26LW, 13 October 2026.
- Common Crawl, CC-MAIN-2026-43, October 2026: the URL index and the WARC files.
- Trakis, every check the audit runs, and what an SEO audit is, where rows and problems are first counted.
Last changed 13 November 2026.